It's great that you're actually having this discussion -- something I'm sure a lot of creators never do. In my opinion, book piracy is a pretty hard thing to do "properly". Sure, if an un-DRM'd PDF is available, it's easy to copy and share the text and images that make up the book, but it's arguable if that copy is really a book, or just a wrapper containing the IP that would normally be realized on paper. It's not the same product -- as opposed to music or videos, which are (generally) indistinguishable whether purchased on CD/DVD or downloaded via The Pirate Bay. If you actually wanted to go to the lengths of printing out a PDF of a book and binding it in some reasonable fashion, I suspect it would quickly become more expensive (time + materials) than purchasing the book itself. Given this point of view, I would argue that if someone were to download a PDF of the book, chances are they would only read enough of it to determine if there is value in purchasing the (MUCH easier to use) paper copy or not. If they don't find the book valuable based on the PDF, the download isn't a lost sale as they wouldn't have purchased it anyway. I can anticipate two problems with this way of thinking: 1. People who read entire book on computer and find it valuable/satisfying: I can't foresee this happening very often -- it's HARD to read great amounts continuously on a computer (or at least I find it to be so). This would be a lost sale, but I can't honestly foresee it occurring that often, and it would likely become less and less feasible as the page count increases. 2. People using the book as a reference: I see this as being a bigger problem. If someone doesn't want to read your whole book but finds certain sections valuable as a reference, they're likely to hold onto the PDF and search it or jump to those particular sections. It's tough to say if this is a lost sale or not, and this is perhaps the only case where I could see a DRM'd PDF ebook doing more good than harm. The purchaser is effectively not saddled with a whole stack of paper when all they wanted is a chapter, and you/your publisher is compensated for the use of that chapter. For a non-DRM alternative, this would perhaps be a good situation for a "pay what you think is appropriate" arrangement, similar to Radiohead's In Rainbows album distribution. Maybe some market research is required to see if people find DRM'd PDF ebooks valuable/satisfying? Anyway, given that a non-DRM'd ebook is not an option, I'm not sure what I would do. The DRM'd book would allow for additional sales AND could be very valuable for certain users (people who only want part of it, and/or want to search it). But, it could also be frustrating for those users (closed-source reader, etc.), reduce physical book sales as Russell mentioned, and involves the privacy issues of the embedded email address. If you decide not to go with the ebook, you have a great opportunity to include a statement explaining to your publisher why you made that decision. This option could allow you to stick to your principles while making it clear to the publisher why you are doing so, which could potentially lead to a change in their policies in future.